Firstly, you should check out the G+ post for even more scathing commentary on my original post.
Next, you should see the followups (in case you haven't already):
- Complexity blog: Things a complexity theorist....
- Turing's invisible hand: Things an AGTer....
- Peter Krautzberger (on Boole's rings): Things a set theorist..
- Computational Combinatorics: Things a graph theorist...
- Quantum Pontiff: Things a quantum information theorist ....